Editor's Quote: "The test of democracy is freedom of criticism". D. Ben-Gurion
About us
  • IQ4News
  • Contact Us
  • Become a Contributor
  • Contributors
  • Charity of the Month Application
  • Advertising
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Copyright Notice
  • Feedback
IQ4News, Ubuntu through New Media
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Sport
  • Art & Entertainment
  • Technology
  • Education
More
  • Health and Medicine
  • Environment
  • Development
  • Media
  • Only in Africa
  • Opinion
  • IQ4News TV & Audio
  • iThink
  • Special Coverage
Wednesday 23rd May 2012, 4:21 UTC
Home

Nigerian Mother is jailed for Sending Son Home for Discipline

Professional Journalist: Yemisi Akinbobola Tuesday, 15 February, 2011 - 09:32
Opinion
Source: IQ4News
Opinion

Nigerian Mother is jailed for Sending Son Home for Discipline

Editor's Choice

Most...

  • Viewed
  • Commented
1. KENYA: Survey Report Paints a Grim Picture on the Economy
2. KENYA: What is the Election Date?
3. African economic growth must translate into positive change #ADFSOAS
4. TANZANIA: Court declines to entertain and adjudicate on EALA Members term in...
5. UGANDA: Daily Monitor Journalist Assaulted in Prison
1. KENYA: What is the Election Date?
2. African economic growth must translate into positive change #ADFSOAS
3. UGANDA: Daily Monitor Journalist Assaulted in Prison
4. TANZANIA: Court declines to entertain and adjudicate on EALA Members term in...
5. Mediation and Security Council Proposes Measures to Address Threats to the...

Submitted by Yemisi Akinbobola on Tue, 15/02/2011 - 9:32am

Yemisi Akinbobola's picture
I ask how far should the law go in interefering with parenting styles?

The BBC and the Press Association reported a piece of news today that got me quite frightened for Nigerian parents in the UK; and indeed all parents and family from societies that believe in disciplining children so that they do not go off the rails.

In this particular case, the wife of a special adviser to the Delta State Governor, Lydia Erhire, was jailed in the UK, not for corruption charges, but for sending her 17 years old son, Edirin Onogeta-Idogun, back to Nigeria because of his bad behaviour.

Many Nigerians will agree this has been a normal trend for parents who want their unruly children that live in Western countries to go back home and learn the African way of obedience to your parents and other behaviours associated to a good child in our societies.

As I read both the Press Association and BBC reports, I was shocked at how the mother in question was demonised, and how her actions were made to look like it was not for the benefit of the child.

What was most shocking was that she was arrested under the Forced Marriage Protection Order, because her son, Edirin, claimed he would be made to marry against his will.

Demonized Parenting Styles

The BBC wrote:

“Last year he feared he may be taken to Nigeria and forced to marry against his will, his solicitors said, and a Forced Marriage Protection Order was issued on 8 July.”

Now, I may be wrong in this case, but this is not the usual practice with parents of 17 year old boys in Nigeria.

As a Nigerian, and knowing of so many cases of parents sending their children home from the West because of the bad behaviours they pick up from the societies there, I am frightened as I realise that the laws in the UK may have found a way to infiltrate how African parents raise their children in the UK.

What the Press Association wrote sounded more like the truth, but read how they demonized what is otherwise considered, in our societies, ‘for the benefit of the child’:

“Mrs Justice Macur, who sentenced Mrs Erhire for her contempt of court, said that information had been received from Edirin that he had been "forced or subjected to procedures which were meant to exorcise him from his disobedience to the will of his parents and to remove him from what they regarded to be unsatisfactory friendships".”

Why use words like ‘exorcise’? This I guess was their way of associating this case with those of the cases of exorcism of children suspected of witchcraft.

Human Rights v Parenting Rights

While I am all for advocating the rights of every individual, I think it is unhealthy where laws interfere with the way we bring up our children.

As a Nigerian observer of this case, I interpret it as the normal situation of

  1. child behaving badly
  2. parents send child back to Nigeria to learn the Nigerian way of life and respect for your parents
  3. child looking for any means necessary to stop this
  4. court takes drastic action because the child’s right was more important that the parenting tactics of his parents.

Mrs Erhire was committed to Holloway Prison for eight months.

Tweet

Post a New Comment

Comment with Facebook

  • adviser
  • Arrest
  • BBC
  • Childhood
  • Conviction
  • Edirin Onogeta-Idogun
  • Education
  • Education
  • Family law
  • Family Relation
  • Governor
  • Holloway Prison
  • International relations
  • Lydia Erhire
  • Macur
  • Marriage
  • Nigeria
  • Nigeria
  • Opinion
  • Parenting
  • Parenting styles
  • Person Career
  • Political geography
  • Time
  • West Africa
  • Debate
  • Opinion
  • Share this IQ4News Article

Comments

#1 Hypocrisy

Submitted by 'Gbenga Ojo (not verified) on Wed, 16/02/2011 - 1:50pm.

It is so disheartening to go through this piece. When is it the right of the British authority to protect the rights of a Nigerian child?

  • reply

#2 This is a sad story. The

Submitted by Taj (not verified) on Tue, 15/02/2011 - 11:49pm.

This is a sad story. The family could be split by the court case. It's a clash of cultures and laws.

Small thing though, neither of the publications "demonized" Nigerian customs. They were both quoting the solicitors (BBC) and the judge (Press Assoc).

  • reply

#3 distorted

Submitted by Jon (not verified) on Tue, 15/02/2011 - 10:03pm.

I'd like to do a piece on this issue.
Fact is that the boy in question is GAY and his parents just like any normal African parents frowned at this.
He is not even a British citizen for crying out loud. His mother lives in the UK on a permanent leave to remain visa while his father lives in Nigeria. The news is still quite disturbing, to say the least. I hope to have the peace of mind to write an article on this! Poor woman!

  • reply

#4 this is outrageous

Submitted by belinda (not verified) on Tue, 15/02/2011 - 6:25pm.

They had  right to do that.no wonder their kids start doing drugs and having sex from very tender ages..if you don't instill discipline in your kids,who will?..in every society there are different parenting styles as a result of that,what may be accepted as the right way to correct a child in nigeria may be condemned in the united states
And vice versa..as long as the parent doesn't resort to violence..

  • reply

#5 This is madness

Submitted by duchess (not verified) on Tue, 15/02/2011 - 10:01am.

This is madness

  • reply

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Your IQ4News
Login | Register | Subscribe
News by Country
, A, B, C, D, E, F, G, I, K, L, M, N, P, Q, R, S, T, U, V, Y, Z
News by Tags
polygamy FISHING World Athletics
Conflict tuaregs VC4Africa
Recession Money Alassane Ouattara
Joseph kony Motorbikes prostitution
Follow Us
  • African News - Twitter
  • African News - Facebook
  • African News - LinkedIn
  • African News - RSS
Poll
Do you agree with Charles Taylor that the ICC is being prejudice by targeting African leaders?:
Photojournalism
  1. EDITORIAL CARTOON: Politics Degree
  2. PHOTO: Zimbabwe Achievers Awards
  3. EDITORIAL CARTOON: Charles Taylor Verdict
  4. EDITORIAL CARTOON: New World Bank Boss
  5. EDITORIAL CARTOON: JZ Marries 4th Wife!
"On the Air"
  1. PODCAST: Analysis of the Mali Coup, the Tuareg and the Reaction of ECOWAS
  2. PODCAST: Analysis of James Ibori’s prosecution by the British, the efficiency of the EFCC, and political influence on policing in Nigeria
  3. Men Who Sleep with Men: Between the Rock and the Hard Place
  4. INTERVIEW: Stepehn Visser on the South African Film Industry
  5. INTERVIEW: Na'ima Robert Talks About Her New Novel 'Far From Home'
IQ4News Partners
Uganda 2012
Africabusiness.com
Onlinenewspaper.com
Africa Renewal
IQ4News promoted Charity

Charity of the Month

IHIVF
Click to Donate
Opinion
Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala - Not Fit for the World Bank top Job
Opinion - Commentary
  •  
  • more
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Copyright Notice
  • Feedback
©IQ4News
Powered by Dharma Media Productions